Who Would You Rather?: American Idol Edition

We haven’t been keeping up with the latest season of American Idol, but it seems like it’s a total sausage fest. Only three of the remaining contestants are of the female persuasion, which makes us wonder when America suddenly decided to start hating women. Not to mention, it also makes us wonder which of these dudes you want to fuck.

Scott McCreery is left off our list for obvious reasons (he’s only 17 years-old), but you have a decent amount of choices with James Durbin, Jacob Lusk, Paul McDonald, Stefano Langone and Casey Abrams. So what do you say? Which one of these hopeful superstars gets your dick hard?

– Dewitt

To check out the full pics and cast your vote, follow the JUMP:

JAMES DURBIN:

JACOB LUSK:

PAUL MCDONALD:

STEFANO LANGONE:

CASEY ABRAMS:




23 thoughts on “Who Would You Rather?: American Idol Edition

  1. STEFANO is HOT!! And I don’t even know why jacob is on the list, she’s practically a woman!

  2. Ive been watching this year, and think they desperately miss Simon, as the new panel (with Randy) LOVE everyone, every week, with very little critical comments…of these guys:

    James is straight version of Adam Lambert, a screamer;
    Jacob, aka Luther Vandeross comes across as really gay;
    Paul is alot like Kenny Loggins to me, with very little variation to his weekly songs;
    Stefano, hottest of the group, but not sure if they is anything truly special there in the voice department; and
    Casey reminds me of a cross behind Will Ferrel and Zach Galifianakis, perhaps he will have a better go at movies.

  3. James, if i could slick down the fauxhawk and make sure he was really clean; Stefano, only after he grows up; Paul only after he breaks his meth addiction; Casey, only if I was reincarnated as one of his fellow hobbits first; and Jacob under no set of circumstances of which I can conceive.

  4. theyre all gross… to be honest, as 100% gay as i am, Pia is the most “handsome” and the obvious winner. these are fuglies. Jacob is the only one i wanna hear sing of these

  5. I don’t watch this show anymore, so I didn’t know anything about any of the contestants other than seeing their pictures. Too bad Scott is not of age, because he was the most attractive of the bunch. So I voted for Paul.

  6. Stefano is the whole package – he has all the ingredients to be a huge pop idol! Not only is he very sexy and handsome, but he has the most impressive vocal range.

  7. Chanbtboy they R all very talented but U R spot on about the none of the above choice in fact if N O A ( none of the above ) where among the choices N O A would run away with the competition …..

  8. R Kelly seriously. This is the second post that I have today with you writing some horribly rude comment. If you do not change your attitude you are going die alone; forever a miserable old women. Stefano is hot.

  9. Without Scotty it’s no contest. Don’t care if he is a chicken. He look about 23.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.