Who Would You Rather?: Sherlock Holmes Edition

who would you rather, Robert Downey Jr., Jude Law, Sherlock Holmes, Watson, film, Guy Ritchie, movies, Christmas 2009, naked, abs, promo, six pack, gay

It seems like just yesterday that I was sporting a tent in anticipation of Guy Ritchie's Sherlock Holmes adaptation, and I almost busted my zipper when I found out that there may be some homoerotic tension between Sherlock Holmes and his dear Watson. It probably helped that the two characters will be portrayed by Robert Downey Jr. and Jude Law

Of course, that leads to us making some tough decisions. If you had to choose between Robert Downey Jr. and Jude Law, who would you rather? Let's hope that ol' Sherlock's six pack can compete with these naked pictures of Watson.

– Dewitt

To cast your vote, follow the JUMP:

Online Surveys & Market Research

16 thoughts on “Who Would You Rather?: Sherlock Holmes Edition

  1. Tough call. I prefer Downey’s face and personality, but Law’s got a nicer body.
    I voted for Downey, but I’d rather share a bed with both.

  2. I think Downey is incredibly sexy as well in his own way, but I’ve always had a thing for Jude Law… Just something about him has always made my cock twitch.

  3. After reading past interviews with Downey you’d have a better chance with him…This one is a tough call but I’d give Downey a slight edge.

  4. I have absolutely no interest in seeing this movie because of all of the action/fight scenes I’ve seen in the previews. Wasn’t Sherlock Holmes a mystery? Since when does he practice martial arts? Why are there explosions and car chases?

  5. interesting note–in an early role in his career Law was in an episode of Sherlock Holmes in the british television series from Granada television–in the episode he had to dress as a woman. Jeremy Brett played Holmes, and Brett was, it was said, family . . .

  6. Sherlock might say it’s all elementary Watson ” but Watson as of right now is kicking Sherlock ass n this contest !!!
    Robert Downey looks more like a wino on a Saturday night than he does Sherlock Holmes!!!

  7. Funny, as I alwasys thought the role of Watson was being played by Ewan McGregor! Doesn’t Ewan and Jude look alike, or is it just me?

  8. Law is a sleazy, over sexed pig who cant keep is pants zipped(ie child support payments). Downey all the way baby.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.