Remember that guy who played the sexy gardener on Desperate Housewives? Even though he wasn't much of an actor, Jesse Metcalfe was definitely a fine piece of ass. But does he still got it? Splash News recently captured the actor on film, and it looks like he's put on some weight, grown a goatee, stopped waxing and got a tattoo. So who would you rather–the old Jesse or the newly cubby Jesse?
Not that you asked, but I'm voting for the latter. The old Jesse was a little too plastic for my tastes. It'd be like fucking a Ken doll! And in case you're wondering, this isn't the first time we've asked you to choose between two versions of the same guy. Check out a couple of similar entries here and here.
UPDATE: A friend of the Daily claims that he allegedly hooked up with Mr. Metcalfe. Discuss.
– Dewitt
For a closer look at these photos, follow the JUMP:
Either way, but you’re right the more natural, slightly hairy would be hotter for me…
How about some details on the hook up…so is Jesse, top or bottom?
I am votting fo the old Jesse.
would pretty much do anything at any time w/ cubby jesse. woof!
yep, the old one was too plastic. like barbie (or ken as u mentioned).
nice to look at, but nothing more.
down with plastic!
(and that includes his plucked eyebrows)
I hook up with both. He’s hot both ways and I would love to get my hands on his hot ass
Hands down the new Jesse! I like hair and beef (especially layered over muscles). Facial hair is a HUGE plus! Tats are a turn on as well as long as not overdone. The eyebrows on the other hand…makes an otherwise masculine appearing man look nelly.
the old, absolutely. i like younger-looking guys. tatoos are a bit of a turn-off. same with extra weight.
to each his own.
it’s amazing how radically any person can transform his appearance.
as for me, i like the look of New Jesse — he appears less likely to Queen Out on me, and, also appears to be quite nice to cuddle with, at night.
none of you could have either.
JUST SAYING = )
Yeah, I always thought he was way too manicured before. More than anything, it was the eyebrows that usu set me off. Can’t really see the latter pic but I would guess that his features couldn’t have changed that much. Regardless, he is a rather attractive man. Not rough around the edges enough for me but still HOT!
I would do Old Jesse, but New Jesse is way better (as far as I can tell from the pic).
Erik, you’re right, of course, but self-delusional fantasizing is just plain fun.
I’LL TAKE THE NEW ONE
I’d take him no matter what…Metcalfe is one very sexxxy centaur
He is hot man and I would do any thing in sex he like
gimme him a little real any day! woof!
Mmmmm, the beefier one!!