Separated at Birth: American Idol Contestants and Shrek Characters

Allison and Fiona

Every now and then you get someone on American Idol who looks like a famous celebrity. Unfortunately, our girl Allison from this season looks like Fiona from Shrek… in her ogre form. I mean if Allison doesn't win American Idol, she can always replace Sutton Foster in the Broadway version of Shrek. She would be a shoe-in for the role of Fiona.

Melinda and Shrek 

What's a Fiona without a Shrek? Well, we found the perfect former American Idol contestant who can replace Brian James D'arcy as Shrek in the Broadway version. Wouldn't you agree that Melinda Doolittle bears a striking resemblance to everyone's favorite ogre? The fact that she has a very short neck doesn't help her much.

Anyways, I obviously am just kidding when I say these things and both contestants have amazing voices. At least they both have careers on Broadway if their music aspirations go nowhere. Thoughts?

– Andy

2 thoughts on “Separated at Birth: American Idol Contestants and Shrek Characters

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.