Hot or Not: Mustaches

It’s time for another hypothetical scenario! You’re chatting with an attractive gentleman on Manhunt, making plans for him to come over to your place. In his profile pictures, he’s either clean-shaven, scruffy or sporting a beard. Honestly, this all depends on your personal preference, but the general point is that you think he’s extremely hot…

When he shows up to your place, it turns out that he’s grown or trimmed himself a full mustache. Are you inclined to break out your razor and tell him to shave? Or does the new look turn you on? In other words, what are your thoughts on mustaches–hot or not?

– Dewitt

Photo credit: Island Studs

To check out more photos of Kyle and his mustache, follow the JUMP:

Unrelated bonus shots:

44 thoughts on “Hot or Not: Mustaches

  1. I kind of like them. It really depends on the person, though. Like this Island Stud, I think he looks good. I like a full, furry mustache, but if it looks like puberty hasn’t kicked in or its too stylized, then I say lose it.

  2. Mustaches alone make people look like 80’s porn stars, and not the really good ones’ either. So, I would have to say this stud would look better after I gave him the razor.

  3. Love them! I grew up in the 70’s so all my childhood crushes sported big ones. I’ve never recovered…..

  4. Not…unless you’re a 70s porn star…agree on the rimming, but add a goatee to send me over the edge…as fot this stud, buz the stash like his pubes…

  5. Have always had a thing for moustaches, ever since I was at IU and Mark Sptiz won all his gold medals. I always thought he looked like he stepped out of a hot 70’s porn film.

  6. Moustaches are totally, totally masculine and hot. Cleanshaven guys rarely turn my crank at all; they have to REALLY REALLY have it going on, which is unfortunately rare. Facial hair improves basically any man who has the cojones to be able to grow it.

  7. Some guys look great in ‘staches, some don’t. As long as they’re well-trimmed, I like them. I don’t like the bushy, untrimmed type, tho. Same goes for beards. Closely-trimmed & neat is sexy to me. Anything else is a turn-off. I used to have a van dyke…..well-trimmed mustache & goatee joined together. It really got a lot of notice from other guys. And honestly speaking, I look damn good with one…ha! But I had to start dying mine & it got to be a hassle to upkeep, especially now that there’s not anyone around here to notice. A bit of facial scruff is sexy on most guys, too.

  8. Hey. If it’s for Movember, I don’t care. Means he’s aware of and wants to spread awareness of prostrate cancer. and thats hot in my books 🙂

  9. Most men have some kind of facial hair (I’m told some Native Americans don’t ?) so, if you’re a gay man you should like it & expect it, unless you like boys or women 😉 Of course, good grooming is always desired.

    P.S. It feels great between the cheeks & takes rimming to the ultimate level ! ;-{~

  10. It totally depends upon the guy…some guys look ridiculous in them…some guys, like a Tom Selleck, are smoking HOT with them…I love men with facial hair, so I generally go gaga over a guy who not only has the mustache, but a nicely trimmed full beard as well…oh, and they ARE great for rimming…I love the smell of a guy’s ass on my mustache after I have been rimming him…woof…

  11. NOT. If it’s part of a more complete beard/goatee I would say yes, but I don’t find the standalone mustache to be attractive in the slightest.

  12. If I wanted to stick my d*ck into something surrounded by fur, I’d date chicks. I get that some people like facial hair (my young man does) and I even get that some guys look good with it. But nothing is worse that a hot, smooth, younger guy (like the Island Stud portrayed above) sporting ugly facial hair. And that moustache is definitely ugly facial hair. It completely ruins his looks.

  13. Not. It’s one of the few things I would ever consider a deal-breaker. Not to mention, this guy could be gorgeous without the ‘stache, yet he looks like a creepy uncle with it.

  14. Moustaches, in my eyes, are a sure fire way to look less attractive. Moustache November is for a good cause, I get it, but I’ve never seen more potentially hot guys become less hot by sprouting some rather unfortunate upper lip hair. I think they’re hilarious, and I think that the idea of them is amusing, but in actuality I have no attraction to the moustache clad whatsoever.

  15. I’ll have to agree with most of the guys here, typically mustaches don’t look good on guys by themselves. But goatees rock!

  16. I’ll have to agree with most of the guys here, typically mustaches don’t look good on guys by themselves. But goatees rock!

  17. there are a lot of guys today who could learn a lot from 80s porn stars….they were real men, none of this shaved, styled, hairless buffed nonsense….mustaches ALWAYS depend on the guy….some guys look better with and some without. but don’t make some blanket statement….its like saying ALL gay men are fem, or ALL gay men need to manscape….absolutes breed absolutes….

  18. Not crazy about this guy or his mustache (his looks stupid).

    As for me, never had a mustache until I suffered a serious injury, was unable to work for almost 6 months, so grew a goatee. Decided to keep it when I returned to work, and its now going on 16 years! Would feel odd without it now, like my old high school picture.

    Find I am more attracted to guys with facial hair, as well as hairy bodies- shaved twinks do nothing for me. Give me a hairy bear-type guy, who can suck and fuck, as well as cuddle later. 🙂

  19. Depends on the guy, if he can grow a full one. Pencil-thin ones don’t work, bushy or untrimmed ones are a turn-off. And several-day’s growth (AKA stubble) are a sign of laziness–either you’re all in or not.

  20. boy, this is a busy post, I did not read everything….

    anyway, I think that in most guys it looks cute… a mustache, which is not conventional anymore, for me, is similar to a guy wearing a fun hat or cool sneakers…. it sort of shows a playful side to them…

    if the guy above knocked on my front door and smiled at me I’d ask him to marry me on the spot…. okay, we’d have to take a quick trip to Canada……. I think he is just perfect……

    nice body that is not too ripped, great smile, and sexy stache…..

  21. Some men look hot with a moustache while others don’t. I think Kyle looks extremely hot and sexy with his moustache.

    The question is: “How important is it to you?”
    If you’re meeting the guy for a one-night-stand do you really care whether he’s grown or trimmed himself a full mustache? You’re hooking-up for sex and nothing else so who cares?

    If, on the other hand, you really like the guy and are interested in developing a relationship then the question remains: “does it really matter that much that he’s grown or trimmed himself a full mustache? Isn’t it about the man, his character/ personality and the way you both feel about each other?

    No, it wouldn’t bother me!

  22. Obviously, it depends on the individual; some people can pull it off, while others can’t. Generally, I’d rather they had no moustache: it reminds me too much of my father.

  23. Sal is so right. Men back then were men in their natural state of masculinity. Today’s plastic feminized Ken dolls should make anyone wonder why they’re gay. I read an article (can’t remember where) that the “au natural” look is now coming back for us gay folk. Finally and thankfully. If I wanted to get it on with someone who waxes, plucks, starves and “lifts” to have an hour-glass “figure” and all around looks like Ginger Grant and erstwhile demasculates himself, I’d go to Exodus International to have them “pray” me into being straight.

  24. Moustaches and beards have always been a turn on for me, they accentuate a guys masculinity.

    However it is true that some guys just don’t suit them.

    I think this guy would be hot with or without the ‘tache 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.