Who Would You Rather?: Carter Brothers

This week we’re pitting brother vs. brother… and this isn’t even a post about twincest! After these pictures of Aaron Carter were posted, I wondered which Carter brother would attract the most guys.

Both have gone from looking pretty awful to redeeming themselves, at least in the body department. While “meth face” might be an apt description, we’re still making you pick… just focus on the body! Sometimes there’s nothing wrong with a brown bag fuck anyway right?

– Andy

For muscle picture of both, follow the JUMP:

Aaron:


20 thoughts on “Who Would You Rather?: Carter Brothers

  1. Nick. I always had a bit of a crush on him, and he seems to have gotten his life back on track better than Aaron.

  2. Two Aaron Carter post in a day?? Must be a sloooow day at MH world headquarters to go after low hanging fruit like this, lol!

  3. I’d like Aaron to fuck me up the ass while I’m sucking his brother Nick. When Nick comes in my mouth, I’d turn around and spit his jizz into his baby brother’s mouth. Then, after Aaron finishes dumping his load in my ass, I’d hover over Nick’s mouth and fart his baby brother’s splooge into his mouth.

  4. when i was , i had a crush on aaron. back when lindsey lohan and hillary duff were fighting for him. looking back, i think we’re all saying to ourselves, “what the hell was i thinking”?

  5. This is a joke, right? Nick, of course. Aaron is a no talent Jess McCartney wannabe. Nick at least know he’s a boy band eye candy and had fun with it.

  6. This post is the best argument I have seen so far for a “neither” option. If that seems bitchy and negative, I also support a “both” option. It’s the only way to find out how your readers feel.

  7. Give me circa 2003 Aaron any day. Back when he lived in the Keys.

    Yea. Rip that poor little fucker apart. ._.

  8. Aaron is not that muscular. They must have photo shopped the pic. I know for a fact that it’s not his body.

    HngBlkBtm

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.