Before I even posted last week's epic threeway Who Would You Rather, I had a good hunch about who would be winning and losing. Today's edition doesn't seem like much of a contest either, but you guys have surprised me in the past. Who knows how you'll wind up voting this time around?
In honor of the film Brothers, we've decided to place Tobey Maguire against Jake Gyllenhaal. While we mean no harm to Mr. Maguire, we're starting to wonder if Jake would have more competition from his other co-star Natalie Portman…
– Dewitt
To cast your vote, follow the JUMP:
It’s almost a toss-up. Tobey is coming along nicely.
lol.. hmm… maybe it’s too early to tell who’ll win this… but this is kinda tough… but Jake’s mouth is sexy… yes, not just his lips, or just his teeth, but his overall mouth is sexy…
no toss-up as of 10:50pm of Dec. 2. Jake is leading with more than 90% of the votes. Tobey had to lose weight for this movie, so he doesn’t look quite as nice.
OMG! This is the first Who’d You Rather where I actually feel conflicted to choose, damnit, Lol!
Both soo cute & sexy!
Say what…I’ve guess I’m out of the loop since I’ve never even came close to getting a woody over Toby…sorry.
This is a contest? It is just mean to have Toby there.
no contest
jake is a hottie
toby is a goof
Jake all the way!
Definately Jake
spiderman is a nutrition fiend.
Okay, Jake wins it bar none!!! It’s not fair Tobey that you got put up against a real hottie… but, who said life was fair!
Jake every time! He’s way more manly.
(*i* voted fer ya, tobey, when no one else did…)
Definitely Jake… He at least has looked like he has taken it from behind!!
I want a 4-way with the both of them AND Natalie Portman!
Saint Impatience it sounds more like a sympathy vote 2 me !!! BTW I voted 4 Jake is it just me or r all guys name Jake sexy as all fucking hell
maguire is adorable.
i wanted to throw the guy a token..
..although this was a very horrible slaughter.
(i honestly want to avert my eyes..)
I never get it. I think Jake’s kind of ugly.