Hot or Not?: Huge Cocks

Insert yourself into this hypothetical scenario. While finishing up at work, you receive a text from a guy you chatted with on Manhunt. He tells you that he’s ridiculously horned up, and you should come over as soon as possible. It’s not normally in your nature to do these things (or maybe it is), but you decide to take the risk. After all, you must have liked him enough if you gave him your number!

As soon as you come through the door, the two of you explode into a passionate frenzy. You’re making out against the wall, shirts are lifted over your heads and then you make your way down to undo his fly. Before you even touch the zipper, you notice an extremely large protrusion in his pants. Um, is that his dick? Because it’s practically the size of your forearm.

While groping his monstrous wang in disbelief, he asks you if you like what you see. Never mind what you’d tell him in the actual situation! Be honest with us–are you turned on by his huge cock? Or does it scare the hell out of you?

It may seem like a stupid question to ask whether big dicks are Hot or Not, but that’s not going to stop us from sparking the discussion. When it all comes down to it, does size matter? How about when the size in question is extra large?

– Dewitt

Photo credit: It’s Gonna Hurt

To check out more of Castro and Zack in action, follow the JUMP:

104 thoughts on “Hot or Not?: Huge Cocks

  1. Visually? Hell ya!

    Logistically? I’d rather have something in a more workable size than what’s shown here!

  2. Honestly, i been in those situations…and they are hot to look at and suck but the rest is just wrong…and a big turn off…but Castro’s dick is just unbelievable and a major turn off

  3. Yeah, it’s a turn on… when it’s being done to someone else! I’ve had a couple big ones in my time, but never something that was gargantuan.

  4. I hate big dicks. I have a gag reflex for a reason (I don’t deep throat) and only takes a finger to hit the prostate. Don’t need to see how far my hole can stretch, I really don’t want to know.

  5. Only about 1 out of 1,000 American men has a penis with an erect length of 9 inches or more. It’s an estimate, but these things are hard to study rigorously because the data is usually self-reported and/or derived from small/unfunded studies.

    Manhunt inches aside, if your threshold for success is 9 inches then it’s still quite likely that you’re excluding far more candidates than you’re accepting.

  6. To be honest, I have had a few large cocks in my time. However, if you’re talking huge I’m just not even gonna try, it may be because I don’t bottom that often, but I really don’t wan to have to try that hard to fit something up there. It will look to me like awesome and pain.

    Awesome to play with though!! and they do look good ( except half the huge ones I’ve seen can not decide which way they are pointing!

  7. I find that HUGE cocks rarely get really hard. I’d much rather work with an average hard cock than a huge floppy one.

  8. Not hot; who needs anything that is gonna cause pain before pleasure; and in the end (no pun inteded) maybe just pain, no pleasure

  9. to me a BIG or HUGE cock is a turn-on to LOOK AT, and perhaps to try and SUCK it down, but since i am a TOP, and not a BOTTOM, could not say anything regarding the fucking part….LOL

  10. EWWW.NOT HOT. I have been known to reject guys with freakishly big cocks. I always thought I was the rare gay for not being a size queen

  11. Hot to look at, touch, and suck. Not hot inside me. The biggest I’ve had inside me is about 8.5″ and pretty thick, and it was definitely a huge (no pun intended) challenge. I can’t imagine going any bigger.

  12. I’ve never bottomed but I imagine something that big would hurt a lot. My cock is a little on the larger side from what i hear from guys, dont get me wrong they still love it but I wouldnt want it to be any bigger.
    That being said I do love a nice sized dick on the guy im fucking, its so much more fun to play with, even if its soft (since a lot of guys cant stay hard the whole time theyre getting fucked) than a little one especially if youre going for the reach around!

  13. the first dick i took was 9.5″, and i’ve been with a couple of guys, and i don’t find any pleasure in smaller (average size) cocks. i’d much rather feel the little sting of a big dick and then a huge amount of pleasure than no pleasure with a smaller one.
    dont get me wrong, i wont only go for the big ones, but anything smaller than 7″ or so just will not cut it for me. 🙂

  14. Come on people! Check out the distortion in the lens. It’s fake. It may be large, but not as large as it looks in those pictures.

  15. as the majority I say as well: very nice to look at and fantasize about but prefer a normal sized one for the real thing, even tho Im a top!

    and btw this huge-cock model in those clips is probably the most boring fucker Ive eeever seen! no passion at all – yawn

  16. I could take it might hurt a little but then i would be beggin for a pounding. no such thing as too big for me
    goes of to plan a trip to usa to find this man.

  17. the huge type as that Cuban guy has are unworkable.
    if you watch those ‘it’s gonna hurt’ movies u’ll see that it doesnt even get hard.
    most of their movies are rubbish.
    i have several on my pc. liked only one with Christin i think.

  18. I’m a top, so I don’t know about getting boned. To suck, HELL YEAH, a giant cock is great to look at, hold, and suck. But, ultimately what does it for my is a GIANT LOAD!!!! I’m all for a big, tasty, $$ SHOT!

  19. Not hot! Personally, I prefer them to be small to average. I love to suck on one that I can get most of in my mouth. And I don’t need to know how large my hole can get!

  20. Now, I like the idea of big cock – Anything 9″ or higher just sounds delicious.

    The problem with the pictures, and this is probably just me, is that his dick curves a lot. I don’t like that; so I’d probably be a bit put off by that more than how big it was.

    I’m sure I could give it a go though. 🙂

  21. I would much rather suck a 6″ cock that blows a huge load, than a 10″ cock pumps out a couple of drops.

  22. I’ll answer it this way. I wish I had a huge cock MYSELF. But I’d much rather be with a guy with a small-to-average sized cock. It’s just easier to have fun with, and works just the same.

  23. Being a Vers/Top i bottom sometimes obviously and found that unless its at least 7.5 inches i wont enjoy it. Then again, when i bottom i prefer dominate tops that make me beg them to stop.

  24. I agree with Matt … I also wish I had a huge cock myself. But I’ll put it this way … the “wow” I say when I see and suck a 9″ cock, is much smaller than the “WOOOWWW” that the guy with the 9″ says when he gets a GIANT load from my 6.5″!!!

  25. I actually saw this guy in person. He was working at a strip club in Key West over labor day 2009.

    It’s a huge dick, and it is absolutely real.

    I thought it was really freakish, but I did grab it a bit anyway 🙂

  26. I know a guy that’s got about 10 inches on him, and THICK. It’s fun to hold, play with and suck, although even with sucking its a challenge and I cant use my usual tricks. 😉
    Luckily he’s a bottom, because something that big wouldnt go near my ass!

    So extra large cocks arent that hot. And its true they rarely get fully hard.

    Give me a rock hard 7 inches any day. 😉

  27. not hot… i like an average size cock.. that can be sucked easily…. big cocks like this are a real turn off. and i agree. the cum shot at the end is so fake.. as is many 🙂

  28. I’m a size queen, so I’ve had some pretty big cocks. However, despite my fancy…I’ve noticed the extremely large ones don’t tend to work so well. That, and their owners have such a big ego because of their giant cock, theyre terrible in bed.

    I’d agree with the others, I’d rather have a 7” cock that blows huge loads, than a 10” that cant stay 100% hard and dribbles. *yawn*

    Fun to look at, but not so fun to play with.

  29. 8 t0 9 inches is fine, but a huge cock is just too much to bare,Im a vers and most guys are fine with 6 to 8, more fun at the medium end, can go harder and longer, big cocks are nice tto look at and play with, but u have to be a sex pig to ever get them in, each to their own

  30. Well, i’ve never been faced with one quite like that before, but it’s amazing what some patience, good lube, and a few whiffs of poppers will do for ya. and once you get started, it’s all good.

  31. I don’t mind admiring a huge cock but that’s where it will stop with me. I may try to suck it a little but there is NO WAY its going inside me .I’m mostly a top anyway. I took a large cock once along time ago it didn’t hurt too badly but I was sure glad that he came quickly.

  32. I’ll take a normal-to-big cock any day, over a super-sized cock. Too much to manage…and
    some of those guys can’t really spare enough blood to rock it out totally hard. I like my playmates to tell me how turned on they are…so half-soft cock isn’t making me feel good about myself. sorry

  33. THERE IS A VAST DIFFRENCE BETWEEN BIG AND HUGE.NOT INTO ANYTHING BIGGER THAT 8 INCHES LIKE MYSELF.IF I WANTED TO HAVE HUGE INSIDE ME I WOULD SIT ON A FIRE HYDRANT.

  34. The guy with the largest dick I’ve ever played with was 10″ and fucking thick….I couldn’t even close my fist around it when hard. He was a bottom, too.

    A lot of what guys are saying here is totally true though….they rarely stay hard if they really get hard at all, and they’re more fun to touch, look at and suck on/play with than they would be in your ass.

  35. It just goes to show that the size of a man’s cock can be either a turn on, or a turn off depending which position you’re in. So in short no matter how big a man’s cock is, if you feel the need to try it on for size, go for it.

  36. Hm.. for me as a bottom and through my experiences with some big cocks, they’re LOVELY, but only if that person knows how to use it good with a bottom or the bottom guy needs to make adjustments to make it work pleasurably for him. But yeah, for me, I love big dicks, can feel everything and my penis remains pointed up to the moon when riding those. (Just nothing more than 9 in.)

  37. Well, I figure this guy would be a 6-hour fuck for me. 20 mins to get it completely in, 40 minutes for him to build enough friction to cum (I’d be screaming like a bitch) and 4 hours in emergency having my sigmoid repaired.

  38. It really depends. I’m not turned on by a huge cock per se but more by the man who it’s attached to. I really enjoy ass play and fisting so someone’s huge dong really isn’t going to feel like much to me. So… with that being said, if he’s a total cutie and hung like a horse (or a chipmunk) I’ll definitely be turned on.

  39. Oh yes, definitely! Love them average size but if you get a monster on a hottie whose is not too aggressive and its beautiful thing 😛 lol

  40. mmmhmmmm huge dicks ….. 😛 im not one for fisting or anything of that nature but a tough top with a big dick isssssss sooooooooooooooo hot 😛

    i like to feel my guy deep, not to say i would turn down any average sized guy

  41. Huge dicks are hot, but just not to fuck me with. Also in regards to Castro, you have to be able to maintain an erection to hang with me.

  42. Uh, no. And look, if you need something that big to ‘feel something’ or ‘get any pleasure’, you might as well put a toll booth on your ass cheeks cause it’s basically the same as the Lincoln tunnel. Not that there is anything wrong with that. Just saying. 🙂

  43. Average is fine by me! I hooked up with a guy who had 10.5 inches and I was just sacred. All I could think the whole time was “there is not a single orifice on my entire body that can take house that monster!!” We wound up not doing anything… So I say, no way not hot!

  44. I can honestly say I have never turned down a guy because his dick was too small, or too large. I’ve had guys with 3 inches and (for a few memorable months) a guy with an 11 3/4 incher. He didn’t break anything in me, although we did break a bed once when he was plowing me particularly hard…

  45. Well, speaking as a guy with huge dick, it is hard to find any bottom to take it. Boys love to look at my cock; and sucking is as far they can go. It is probably once in a year I may “find” a bottom who can try taking it. Most boys give up in two minutes or less of trying. I don’t blame them but I can’t find anyone to handle it. It sucks though.

    99.99% I just watch porn and diy.

  46. not enough, u need to come over this way. there is no such thing as too big (well maybe a whale penis). as long as u prep the ass first with tongues and fingers and even toys if it comes down to it, there is no reason the guy shouldn’t be able to take it. unless he’s a whiner, a woman or a quitter. thankyouverymuch 🙂

  47. Taliking as a true SIZR-QUEEN any more than a mouthfull is a waste but thanj fuck I have a big mough

  48. years ago had a guy who was sporting a third leg (about 10 1/2″ and thick as my forearm). forget trying to fuck my ass, the head on his cock was so large, couldn’t fit it in my mouth w/o risk of lock jaw!

  49. Yes, I find big dicks super hot.

    To be honest though, I prefer the idea of having a guy with a big dick as a bottom…

    But yes, Castro’s penis is a big on the crazy side. It might be weird, but I like dicks without a curve in them… Well, maybe it can have a slight curve, but not as much as Castro.

  50. as long as they can keep it hard enough to fuck properly, thick is hot – love that stretched feeling, length looks good, but at some point just gets to a point that “balls deep” is no longer enjoyable. So I guess I pay more attention to girth than length, but don’t turn people down or look them up based on cock-size.

  51. Huge dicks are hot in porn and pics but in real life, they can hinder a really hot fuck session. I love taking a guy down to his balls and I’m sorry, a huge dick can just be unpleasurable. They are great to look at but I’d rather get fucked by an average guy.

  52. This post and the comments just confirm to me that i’m a great bottom.

    My fuck bud is prob about 9inch, and i LOVE it hehe

    The bigger the better

  53. Castro is a skank, but some of the bottoms they find are cute/hot, and they have a lot of facials in their free previews . . .
    As for big cocks in general . . . hot, but i’ve got a real small mouth, so they don’t fit well.

  54. Huge dicks are fine…but like someone said before, only if they can stay hard…Castro seems to have this problem…main reason I like him better as a bottom

  55. Oh yea, they are hot because they’re so rare. I see a lot of cocks in my work and the majority are what I’d consider small (and the guys all seem to think that they have a larger cock than they do…even when I can look right at it and prove them wrong). Yes, there is the erection challenge thing but to be fair it does take a lot of blood to fill those monster ones up. Give me a nice, thick 8 – 9 any day and I’m a happy man.

  56. ….Depends on what I’m going to do with the dick. If it’s the rare occasion I will bottom, biggest I can stand is a 9. If I top, it can be 12 for all I care. Big is nice, but not needed. I’ve fucked some hot guys without massive dicks.

  57. To be honest, I have quite a large cock myself and it’s not all fun and games. The amount of times guys have looked at it and said “no way!”. It’s extremely frustrating when all you want to do is fuck. Probably the only man who complains that it’s too big 🙁

  58. No, Poor guys that have to take big cocks. I feel sorry for you. I dont take dick in my ass anyway. I maybe like to jack off to big cock porn. It still does hurt me to see those poor guys having to take them cocks up their ass.

  59. yeah the few guys that i’ve seen with overly huge cocks have a really hard time of keeping it hard. So what’s the point???

  60. I like big cocks. . . i don’t like it when it’s HUGE like that. I really don’t care about size, as long as they can get the job done.

  61. Huge dicks are fine to play with, and as long as they are slapping me in the chest when he is riding me, but no-way-no-how is it getting near my ass. On another note, Castro is really unattractive.

  62. No, definitely not!! I’ve been told that I have a huge cock, but nothing like this. I’m 8-inches. Ideal cock size for my boyfriend would be average, somewhere around 6-inches. I think smaller cocks are so hot.

  63. Oh I love how the internet warps everybody’s mind as to what a big cock is. Average is 5-6 inches, and in my past those have been fun every time. Somebody said 6-8 is middle of the road… um no… that’s large. Anything over 8 I would say is huge. The thing is many guys just guess the length… or measure and add a couple inches. But my bf I measured at 7 3/4″ long and 5 3/4″ round. That’s a challenge but still feels amazing.

  64. It m ight be ok to maybe give it a one time go of it to just see what it’s like, but not on a regular basis. 8 is fine for me. Just big enough. Maybe 9, but that’s pushing it.

  65. I’ve never been with anyone with a “huge” cock. I have only seen 2 bigger than mine in person (not that I’m huge) but it always gets compliments. I get turned on by seeing them in movies or pics. I feel the same way though, if you want to top me, it better stay hard, because it’s a turn off to have someone that can’t maintain a hard on. And I know, sometimes it’s a physical problem some guys have, sometimes it’s in their minds. But still.

  66. I’ve tried some guys who have REALLY HUGE MONSTROUS dicks twice before… Both were just luck.

    …And sometimes, I’m okay. I just bit down on a pillow (his girlfriend was in the next room sleeping) and made him use half the bottle of astroglide.

    Another time, it was really spur of the moment, and I hadn’t made a habit (yet) of carrying a Magnum XL around.

  67. I’ve tried some guys who have REALLY HUGE MONSTROUS dicks twice before… Both were just luck.

    …And sometimes, I’m okay. I just bit down on a pillow (his girlfriend was in the next room sleeping) and made him use half the bottle of astroglide.

    Another time, it was really spur of the moment, and I hadn’t made a habit (yet) of carrying a Magnum XL around. Needlessly said, the first condom ripped just getting it in, and we were a bit shy on lube, and it simply hurt way, way, way, way too much just getting the first part in.

    I did let him facefuck me though. My throat was sore as fuck for weeks.

    Worth it? Totally.

    Ridiculously huge monster cocks? Fantasy-wise, hot. Reality, not.

  68. Okay, so normally I’m into a big member…Always up for a challenge 😉
    However, this guys dick is DISGUSTING! I honestly think he has elephantitus or something. No no, never never!
    I would run out of the room screaming from that one eyed monster!

  69. I honestly am not into size. I’ve had both ends of the spectrum and I can honestly say that the smaller pleasured me more than the large member. But it may have had something to do with the fact that the ones with the large member didn’t know how to work it like the ones with the smaller members…
    As for the member shown above……. No thanks. The curve is all wrong and…. well… I’ll be kind. I’ll stop there.

  70. to each thier own. Some bottoms…basically grow into that size,,, i have had bottom friends tell me that they could only take a large penis and that the average or smaller could not be felt. It all depends on what you want. we are all different for a reason. top or bottom… So have your fun the way you like it. peace.

  71. I am getting a nice cock on and I will bend a bit so my hot cum will spray my face can you cum in my ass

  72. Personally, I think that it depends on how big it is. Because there is such thing as too much of a good thing. And a thick cock is good and fun, but once it reaches a certain size, it goes from Good Pain to Bad Pain.
    I have my own chart on cock size: 5 – 6: Average, 7 – 8: Big, 9 – 10 : Huge, 11-Up: Not getting anywhere near my ass.
    By the time the dick starts reaching 8.5 to 9 inches, I start getting a little nervous, but I’ll still play, any higher than 9, and no way. I’d like to walk correctly when its all over.

  73. i’m not a regular bottom and so it depends entirely on the expertise of the top; if he knows how to use his big tool, great. 2 guys have given me multiple orgasms without touching myself..amazingly hot.
    i’m not as flexible as i used to be (i was a gymnast) and used to love fucking big-cock guys with them on their back because i could fuck and suck them at the same time. they really liked that.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.