Evan Peters: Were You Feeling “Tate” From “American Horror Story”?

Note – the following contains spoilers for Season 1 of American Horror Story!

My partner and I were HOOKED on American Horror Story this year. We couldn’t get enough of Murder House and it’s completely fucked-up inhabitants, whether they were living (for the time being) or dead.

One major thing we disagreed on, however, was Evan Peters. He played the psychotic perma-teen ghost Tate. Despite Tate having brutally murdered several people, my guy thought he was “hot” and mentioned that everytime he appeared on screen to murder, rape and terrorize. Note – my bf isn’t scary, he just works in IT.

I could not sign off on that! Peters revealed himself to be an incredible actor, but the Kurt Cobain-hair and the constant screaming and crying just killed any sort of lust I might have for the 24-year-old actor. He DID get to play Rubber Man, though, but they didn’t really give you a glimpse of what he had packing under the latex.

This is sort of a spur-of-the-moment “Would You Hit That?” but would you get with that ghost?

– J. Harvey

Photo credit: Tyler Shields

For more pics of Evan Peters, Follow the JUMP:

13 thoughts on “Evan Peters: Were You Feeling “Tate” From “American Horror Story”?

  1. TOTALLY with your boyfriend here, J. Harvey.  Tate/Evan Peters was very, very hot.  And the creepy, wounded thing just added to the appeal.  [SPOILER:] The scene where he tried to seduce half the gay couple was a nice payoff as the season wound to a close.

    Let’s hope Ryan Murphy doesn’t muck up the second season of AHS like he did with Glee.  Apparently, the series is moving to another location and its unclear if the incomparable Jessica Lange will return or, if she does, if she will continue to play Constance.

  2. My partner is the same. Everytime he sees “Tate” onscreen he says the guy is so cute and adorable. Yeah, in a maniac serial killer way I guess. Not my type. My favorite guy in the show was the blonde gay guy Tate murdered along with his partner.

  3. My boyfriend described his lust for Christopher Meloni as follows: “He looks like he’d hurt me, and I’d like it.”

    Perhaps Tate’s appeal is similar? I don’t know.

  4. I think he’s physically stunning, but the character is beyond frightening.  The school shooting scene–I can’t believe that even made it to cable TV.  I’ll take Dylan McDermott.

  5. hes a beautiful man, and amazing job playing the character. much better dressed though, a bit to twinkish to be “hot”.  ditto on the seduction scene KLB mentioned, the blonder half of the doomed gay couple was most doable.

  6. I’m as gay as they come, but i’d probably stick it to the (young, haha) maid in that show. i hope they make good use of that actress in the future!

  7. Sure, I’ll hit that, just as soon as I hit Jeffrey Dahmer and Ted Bundy…  Dylan McDermott was the beefcake of that show.

  8. HELL YES I’d fuck him! In a New York Minute!!! I hope they bring him back to play another character next season! And all of you people comparing him to actual psychos… you’re all morons. He’s such an amazing actor that he made you believe that’s who he truly is. And that makes him even hotter than his looks already do!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.